Case Name: Conservation Council for Hawai‘i, et al., v. National Marine Fisheries Service, et al.
Nature of Case: AWI and its co-plaintiffs brought claims against the National Marine Fisheries Service and the US Navy over its five-year plan for testing and training activities in the Hawaii-Southern California Training and Testing (HSTT) Study Area. The operations include active sonar and explosives, which are known to cause permanent injuries and deaths to marine mammals and sea turtles.
Court: United States District Court for the District of Hawaii
Year Filed: 2013
Plaintiffs: Animal Welfare Institute; Center for Biological Diversity; Conservation Council for Hawai‘i; Ocean Mammal Institute
Defendants: National Marine Fisheries Services; United States Department of Commerce (Penny Pritzker, Secretary of Commerce); United States Department of the Navy; United States Department of Defense (Chuck Hagel, Secretary of Defense).
- The hearing on the motions for summary judgment took place before Judge Mollway on March 4, 2015. The court issued a favorable decision on March 31, 2015. Then on September 14, 2015, Judge Mollway entered an order settling this case and the related case, Natural Resources Defense Council, et al. v. National Marine Fisheries Service, et al., securing long-sought protections for whales, dolphins, and other marine mammals by limiting Navy activities in vital habitat. The settlement stems from the court’s March 31 finding that the Navy’s activities illegally harm more than 60 separate populations of whales, dolphins, seals, and sea lions.
- Amended Order Granting Conservation Council's Motion for Summary Judgement, Granting NRDC’s Motion for Summary Judgement, Denying NRDC’s Motion for Leave to Submit Extra-Record Evidence, and Granting in Part and Denying in Part Defendant's Motion to Strike submitted on March 31, 2015
- Plaintiffs’ Amended Memorandum in Support of Motion for Summary Judgment submitted on January 23, 2015
- Plaintiffs’ Amended Reply Memorandum in Support of Motion for Summary Judgment submitted on January 23, 2015
AWI and three other groups filed suit against the US Navy and the National Marine Fisheries Service (NMFS), claiming that these government entities violated the National Environmental Policy Act (NEPA, 42 U.S.C. §§ 4321 et seq.) when they relied on a legally defective environmental impact statement to give the green light to the Navy’s five-year plan for testing and training activities off Hawaii and Southern California, which the Navy and NMFS admitted will cause nearly 9.6 million instances of harm to whales, dolphins and other marine mammals—including 155 marine mammal deaths and over 2,000 permanent injuries—and will kill up to 85 critically imperiled sea turtles. NEPA requires that a range of alternatives be considered, including alternatives that could be pursued with less environmental harm, and that the public have an opportunity to review and comment on that analysis. The groups went to court because NMFS approved the Navy’s plan without evaluating any alternatives that would place biologically important areas off-limits to training and testing.
The amended complaint, filed on January 15, 2014, further claimed that in authorizing the Navy’s training and testing, NMFS violated its legal duty under the Endangered Species Act (16 U.S.C. §§ 1531 et seq.) to protect endangered whales and turtles from extinction and under the Marine Mammal Protection Act (16 U.S.C. §§ 1361 et seq.) to prevent harm to marine mammal populations.
Ocean mammals depend on hearing for navigation, feeding, and reproduction. Scientists have linked military sonar and live-fire activities to mass whale beaching, exploded eardrums, and even death. In 2004, during war games near Hawaii, the Navy’s sonar was implicated in a mass stranding of up to 200 melon-headed whales in Hanalei Bay, Kauai. The Navy and NMFS estimate that, over the plan’s five-year period, training and testing activities will result in thousands of animals suffering permanent hearing loss, lung injuries, or death. Millions of animals will be exposed to temporary injuries and disturbances, with many subjected to multiple harmful exposures.
Earthjustice, which filed the lawsuit, represented Conservation Council for Hawai‘i, AWI, the Center for Biological Diversity and the Ocean Mammal Institute in this matter.
- Navy Training and Testing Activities Imperil Marine Mammals and Sea Turtles in Waters off Hawaii and Southern California – AWI Press Release
- Lawsuit Seeks to Reduce Harm to Whales, Dolphins from Navy Sonar in Pacific – AWI Press Release
- Court Rules Navy Training in Pacific Violates Laws Meant to Protect Whales, Sea Turtles – AWI Press Release
- Military Readiness: Incidental Take Authorizations – NOAA Fisheries
- Agency: Dolphins’ Cause of Death Unclear, Human Role Likely – Associated Press